Holiday Gift Guide: Top 15 New Shotguns on GunBroker for 2026

Finding the right gift for the shooter or hunter on your list gets easier when you know what fellow gun owners are actually buying. This holiday gift guide is built on GunBroker’s monthly Top Selling Reports, ranking the 15 new shotguns that sold best on GunBroker across the new over/under, pump-action, semi-auto and side-by-side shotgun categories from January through September 2026.

The list is led by the Stoeger Coach Gun, the Mossberg 590 and the Beretta A300 Ultima, and it includes five semi-autos, four pumps, three over/unders and three side-by-sides. Mossberg placed four models, the most of any brand. Whether you are shopping for a waterfowler, a clay shooter or someone who wants a dependable home-defense shotgun, the picks below are grounded in nine months of GunBroker sales data.

What New Shotguns Sold Best on GunBroker in 2026?

From January through September 2026, the top-selling new shotguns on GunBroker were the Stoeger Coach Gun, the Mossberg 590 and the Beretta A300 Ultima. The Coach Gun ranked No. 1 among new side-by-sides every month, the 590 led new pumps five times, and the A300 Ultima topped new semi-autos in six of nine months.

How We Built This New Shotgun Gift Guide

Each month, GunBroker ranks the best-selling new models in every major firearm category. For this guide, we scored the monthly Top 5 in the new over/under, pump-action, semi-auto and side-by-side shotgun categories for January through September 2026 (nine monthly reports), awarding five points for a No. 1 finish down to one point for No. 5. Ties were broken by the number of months a model appeared in the Top 5, then by No. 1 finishes, then by its most recent Top 5 finish. Models are ranked as GunBroker lists them, so variants such as the Mossberg 590 and 590A1 are counted separately. Each pick is paired with the type of shooter or hunter it suits best.

Top 15 New Shotguns on GunBroker: 2026 Holiday Gift Guide

The list below is ranked from No. 15 to No. 1, counting down to the best-selling new shotgun on GunBroker from January through September 2026.

No. 15: Benelli M4 — Best Gift for the Tactical Shotgun Enthusiast

The Benelli M4 finished No. 2 among new semi-auto shotguns in March and June and added Top 5 finishes in January and February.

The M4 uses Benelli’s gas-operated ARGO system and was adopted by the U.S. Marine Corps as the M1014. It is a premium gift for the tactical shotgun enthusiast.

Months in the new semi-auto shotgun Top 5: January (No. 5), February (No. 4), March (No. 2), June (No. 2)

🎥 Related video: A Look at the Benelli M4 Tactical Shotgun

No. 14: Mossberg 590 Shockwave — Best Gift for the Compact-Firearm Fan

The Mossberg 590 Shockwave appeared in the new pump-action Top 5 five times, with best finishes of No. 3 in March and June.

The Shockwave pairs a 14-inch barrel with a bird’s-head Raptor grip, and it is classified under federal law as a firearm rather than a shotgun. State and local laws vary, so check them before you buy. For the right owner, it is a compact pump that is fun to shoot.

Months in the new pump-action shotgun Top 5: March (No. 3), April (No. 4), May (No. 4), June (No. 3), August (No. 5)

🎥 Related video: Features of Mossberg Shockwave: A Misunderstood But Sweet To Shoot Pump Action Firearm

No. 13: Benelli Super Black Eagle II — Best Gift for the Late-Season Duck Hunter

The Benelli Super Black Eagle II finished No. 2 among new semi-auto shotguns in January, February and April. It tied the Beretta A300 on points and placed one spot behind it on the months-in-Top-5 tiebreaker.

The Super Black Eagle II is the predecessor to Benelli’s SBE3, built on the same inertia-driven semi-auto design and chambered for 3.5-inch 12-gauge shells, with Benelli’s ComforTech recoil-reduction stock. It is a strong gift for the duck hunter who hunts hard through the late season.

Months in the new semi-auto shotgun Top 5: January (No. 2), February (No. 2), April (No. 2)

No. 12: Beretta A300 — Best Gift for the Versatile Semi-Auto Shooter

The Beretta A300 appeared in the new semi-auto shotgun Top 5 four times, with a best finish of No. 2 in July.

Beretta’s A300 line includes the Outlander hunting models and the Patrol defensive models, all built around a gas-operated action. It is a versatile gift for someone who wants a semi-auto for the field, the range or the home.

Months in the new semi-auto shotgun Top 5: May (No. 3), June (No. 3), July (No. 2), September (No. 4)

No. 11: GForce Arms GFY-1 — Best Gift for the Bullpup Enthusiast

The GForce Arms GFY-1 ranked No. 1 among new semi-auto shotguns in May and June and added Top 5 finishes in March and July.

The GFY-1 is a magazine-fed semi-auto shotgun in a bullpup layout, which places the action behind the grip for a shorter overall length. It is a conversation-piece gift for the shooter who likes unconventional designs.

Months in the new semi-auto shotgun Top 5: March (No. 3), May (No. 1), June (No. 1), July (No. 5)

No. 10: Mossberg 590A1 — Best Gift for the Duty-Grade Pump Fan

The Mossberg 590A1 appeared in the new pump-action shotgun Top 5 five times, with a best finish of No. 2 in May.

The 590A1 is the heavy-duty version of the 590, built to military specifications with a heavy-walled barrel and a metal trigger guard and safety. It is a strong gift for the shooter who wants a duty-grade pump.

Months in the new pump-action shotgun Top 5: April (No. 3), May (No. 2), June (No. 4), July (No. 3), September (No. 3)

No. 9: Stoeger Coach Gun Supreme — Best Gift for the Western-Style Collector

The Stoeger Coach Gun Supreme finished No. 2 among new side-by-side shotguns in March and April and No. 3 in January, February, June and September.

The Supreme is an upgraded version of the Coach Gun with dressier wood and finish options. It is a fitting gift for the Western-style collector who wants a coach gun with a little extra polish.

Months in the new side-by-side shotgun Top 5: January (No. 3), February (No. 3), March (No. 2), April (No. 2), June (No. 3), September (No. 3)

No. 8: GForce Arms GF5 Business Class — Best Gift for the Budget-Minded Clay Shooter

The GForce Arms GF5 Business Class ranked No. 1 among new over/under shotguns four times, in March, May, August and September, and finished No. 4 in June.

The GF5 is GForce Arms’ value-priced over/under line, and the Business Class version is a dressed-up configuration of that platform. It is a smart gift for the clay shooter who wants an over/under without a premium price tag.

Months in the new over/under shotgun Top 5: March (No. 1), May (No. 1), June (No. 4), August (No. 1), September (No. 1)

🎥 Binge Watch GunBroker Product Spotlight Videos

No. 7: CZ Bobwhite — Best Gift for the Classic Side-by-Side Fan

The CZ Bobwhite finished No. 2 among new side-by-side shotguns four times, in February, May, June and August, and No. 3 in March and July. It tied the GForce Arms GF5 Business Class on points and earned the higher spot with one more month in the Top 5.

The Bobwhite is CZ’s affordable side-by-side, built with double triggers and a straight English-style stock for quick handling. It is a great gift for the hunter who has always wanted a traditional double gun.

Months in the new side-by-side shotgun Top 5: February (No. 2), March (No. 3), May (No. 2), June (No. 2), July (No. 3), August (No. 2)

No. 6: Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon I — Best Gift for the Upland Bird Hunter

The Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon I finished No. 2 among new over/under shotguns five times, in January, March, April, June and July, and No. 3 in May and September.

Made in Italy, the 686 Silver Pigeon I pairs Beretta’s low-profile over/under action with an engraved silver receiver and walnut stock. Its balance and classic looks make it a fitting gift for the upland bird hunter.

Months in the new over/under shotgun Top 5: January (No. 2), March (No. 2), April (No. 2), May (No. 3), June (No. 2), July (No. 2), September (No. 3)

No. 5: Browning Citori — Best Gift for the Sporting Clays Shooter

The Browning Citori ranked No. 1 among new over/under shotguns in January, February, April and July, and appeared in the Top 5 all nine months.

Introduced in 1973, the Citori is Browning’s flagship over/under family, with field, sporting and trap models known for their fit, finish and durability. It is a gift the sporting clays shooter can use for decades.

Months in the new over/under shotgun Top 5: January (No. 1), February (No. 1), March (No. 3), April (No. 1), May (No. 2), June (No. 3), July (No. 1), August (No. 3), September (No. 2)

🎥 Related videos: Browning Citori 825 Shotgun Lineup Expands for 2026
Highlights of the Browning Citori 825 Pro Sporting Over/Under Shotgun

No. 4: Mossberg Maverick 88 — Best Gift on a Budget

The Mossberg Maverick 88 ranked No. 1 among new pump-action shotguns in January, July, August and September, and appeared in the Top 5 all nine months.

The Maverick 88 is Mossberg’s value-priced pump-action line, and it shares many parts with the Mossberg 500 while using a crossbolt safety. Its low price and dependable design make it one of the easiest shotgun gifts on a budget.

Months in the new pump-action shotgun Top 5: January (No. 1), February (No. 2), March (No. 2), April (No. 2), May (No. 3), June (No. 2), July (No. 1), August (No. 1), September (No. 1)

No. 3: Beretta A300 Ultima — Best Gift for the All-Around Wingshooter

The Beretta A300 Ultima ranked No. 1 among new semi-auto shotguns six times, in January, February, March, April, July and August, and appeared in the Top 5 all nine months.

The A300 Ultima is a gas-operated semi-auto known for soft recoil, oversized controls and easy maintenance, with versions set up for field, waterfowl, turkey and clay shooting. It is a versatile gift for the wingshooter who wants one shotgun for most of the season.

Months in the new semi-auto shotgun Top 5: January (No. 1), February (No. 1), March (No. 1), April (No. 1), May (No. 2), June (No. 4), July (No. 1), August (No. 1), September (No. 2)

🎥 Related videos: New for 2026: Beretta A300 Ultima Patrol 20 Gauge Shotgun | Features & Specs
Beretta A300 Ultima Patrol Shotgun
Highlights of the Beretta A300 Ultima Sporting Shotgun

No. 2: Mossberg 590 — Best Gift for the Home-Defense Shopper

The Mossberg 590 ranked No. 1 among new pump-action shotguns five times, from February through June, and finished No. 2 in every other month.

Built for defense and duty use, the 590 is known for its tang-mounted ambidextrous safety, dual extractors and twin action bars, and it is offered in a wide range of configurations. It is a proven gift for someone shopping for a dependable home-defense shotgun.

Months in the new pump-action shotgun Top 5: January (No. 2), February (No. 1), March (No. 1), April (No. 1), May (No. 1), June (No. 1), July (No. 2), August (No. 2), September (No. 2)

🎥 Related video: Features of the Mossberg Professional Series 590 and 940

No. 1: Stoeger Coach Gun — Best Gift for the Cowboy Action Shooter

The Stoeger Coach Gun ranked No. 1 among new side-by-side shotguns in every month from January through September 2026, earning a perfect score in this guide’s ranking and the top spot overall.

The Coach Gun is a short-barreled side-by-side offered in 12 gauge, 20 gauge and .410 bore, with double triggers and an easy-handling length. It has long been a staple of cowboy action shooting, making it a natural gift for anyone who enjoys timed Western-style matches or a classic double gun.

Months in the new side-by-side shotgun Top 5: All nine months, January through September (No. 1 every month)

2026 New Shotgun Gift Guide Takeaways

The Stoeger Coach Gun Went Nine for Nine

The Coach Gun was the only shotgun to rank No. 1 in its category in all nine months covered, earning a perfect score in this guide’s ranking and accounting for every No. 1 new side-by-side finish of the period.

Five Shotguns Never Left the Top 5

The Stoeger Coach Gun, Mossberg 590, Beretta A300 Ultima, Mossberg Maverick 88 and Browning Citori each appeared in their category’s Top 5 in all nine months, marking them as the most consistent sellers of the period.

Mossberg Swept the Pump-Action Category

The Mossberg 590 (five months) and the Mossberg Maverick 88 (four months) claimed every No. 1 new pump-action finish from January through September, and Mossberg placed four models on this list.

Over/Unders Saw a Two-Way Race

The Browning Citori and GForce Arms GF5 Business Class each claimed four No. 1 new over/under finishes, with the Beretta 687 Silver Pigeon III taking the top spot once.

Beretta-Family Brands Led the Brand Count

Mossberg placed four models (590, Maverick 88, 590A1 and 590 Shockwave) and Beretta placed three (A300 Ultima, 686 Silver Pigeon I and A300). Counting Benelli and Stoeger, which are also part of Beretta Holding, the Beretta family of brands filled seven of the 15 spots. GForce Arms placed two, while Browning and CZ each placed one.

Semi-Autos Claimed the Most Spots

Semi-autos took five spots, pumps four, and over/unders and side-by-sides three each, with every action type represented in the top five overall.

Tips for Giving a New Shotgun as a Gift

• Know the laws first. Firearm gifting and transfer rules vary by state and locality, so review federal, state and local requirements before buying a shotgun for someone else.
• Plan for the FFL transfer. Firearms purchased on GunBroker ship to a licensed dealer (FFL), where the transfer is completed.
• Match the gauge and use. Consider whether the recipient hunts waterfowl or upland birds, shoots clays or wants a home-defense shotgun, and which gauge they already shoot.
• Read the listing closely. Review photos, model details, included chokes and accessories, and seller feedback, and ask the seller questions before you bid or buy.
• Round out the gift. Cases, slings, chokes, shells and other accessories are all available on GunBroker.com.

Final Thoughts on the 2026 New Shotgun Gift Guide

From the nine-for-nine Stoeger Coach Gun to Mossberg’s sweep of the pump category, this year’s best-selling new shotguns on GunBroker covered everything from classic doubles to duty-grade pumps and premium waterfowl semi-autos. Each pick earned its place on nine months of real sales data, giving gift shoppers a proven starting point.

Ready to find the right shotgun for someone on your list? Browse new shotguns on GunBroker.com, review each listing carefully and follow all applicable federal, state and local laws and transfer requirements.

Explore More GunBroker Holiday Gift Guides

• Holiday Gift Guide: Top 15 New Handguns on GunBroker for 2026
• Holiday Gift Guide: Top 15 New Rifles on GunBroker for 2026
• Holiday Gift Guide: Top 15 Used Handguns on GunBroker for 2026
• Holiday Gift Guide: Top 15 Used Hunting Rifles on GunBroker for 2026
• Holiday Gift Guide: 5 Great Home Defense Shotguns
• GunBroker’s Collector Gun Gift Guide

More GunBroker Shotgun Content

• Most Popular Used Shotguns on GunBroker – September 2026
• What Is the Best Shotgun for Home Defense?
• The Best Shotguns for Waterfowl Hunting
• 6 Best Shotguns for Hunting
• Bargain Guns: Best Shotgun for the Money
• Tactical Revolution: The Benelli M4 EXT Unleashed