Shopping for the hunter on your list? Start with the rifles fellow hunters actually bought. This holiday gift guide is built on GunBroker’s monthly Top Selling Reports, ranking the 15 used hunting rifles that sold best on GunBroker across the used bolt-action, lever-action and single-shot rifle categories from January through September 2026.
The list is led by the Ruger No. 1, the Winchester 94 and the Winchester Model 70, one leader from each action type. It includes six bolt-action rifles, five single-shot rifles and four lever-action rifles. Remington placed four models, while Winchester and Ruger placed three each. Whether you are shopping for a deer camp traditionalist, a backcountry elk hunter or a young hunter heading out for the first time, the picks below are grounded in nine months of GunBroker sales data.
From January through September 2026, the top-selling used hunting rifles on GunBroker were the Ruger No. 1, the Winchester 94 and the Winchester Model 70. The No. 1 led used single-shot rifles in seven of nine months, the Model 94 led lever actions every month it ranked, and the Model 70 never finished below No. 2.
Each month, GunBroker ranks the best-selling used models in every major firearm category. For this guide, we scored the monthly Top 5 in the used bolt-action, lever-action and single-shot rifle categories for every month from January through September 2026 (nine monthly reports), awarding five points for a No. 1 finish down to one point for No. 5. Ties were broken by the number of months a model appeared in the Top 5, then by No. 1 finishes, then by its September rank. Each pick is paired with the type of hunter it suits best.
| Rank | Used Hunting Rifle | Action | Best Gift For | Months in Top 5 | No. 1 Finishes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ruger No. 1 | Single-Shot | One-Shot Hunter | 9 of 9 | 7 |
| 2 | Winchester 94 | Lever-Action | Deer Camp Traditionalist | 8 of 9 | 8 |
| 3 | Winchester Model 70 | Bolt-Action | Classic Rifleman | 9 of 9 | 1 |
| 4 | Winchester 1894 | Lever-Action | Lever-Action Collector | 8 of 9 | 1 |
| 5 | Remington 700 | Bolt-Action | Do-It-All Big-Game Hunter | 6 of 9 | 6 |
| 6 | New England Firearms Handi-Rifle | Single-Shot | A Young or New Hunter | 9 of 9 | 0 |
| 7 | Thompson/Center Encore | Single-Shot | Multi-Caliber Hunter | 7 of 9 | 0 |
| 8 | Marlin 336 | Lever-Action | Brush-Country Deer Hunter | 7 of 9 | 0 |
| 9 | Remington 700 BDL | Bolt-Action | Walnut-and-Blued-Steel Fan | 8 of 9 | 0 |
| 10 | Remington Rolling Block | Single-Shot | Frontier-History Buff | 9 of 9 | 0 |
| 11 | Ruger M77 | Bolt-Action | Hunter Who Wants a Workhorse | 9 of 9 | 0 |
| 12 | Ruger No. 3 | Single-Shot | Single-Shot Collector | 4 of 9 | 2 |
| 13 | Remington 700 Mountain | Bolt-Action | Backcountry Hunter | 3 of 9 | 2 |
| 14 | Savage 99 | Lever-Action | Vintage Lever-Gun Enthusiast | 6 of 9 | 0 |
| 15 | Mauser M12 | Bolt-Action | European-Rifle Fan | 4 of 9 | 0 |
The list below is ranked from No. 15 to No. 1, counting down to the best-selling used hunting rifle on GunBroker from January through September 2026.
The Mauser M12 ranked No. 4 among used bolt-action rifles in January and February, then climbed to No. 3 in both March and April, earning the final spot on this list.
Mauser’s modern M12, introduced in the 2010s, pairs a smooth bolt-action with clean European styling. For the hunter who appreciates German engineering, a used M12 is a refined gift with a famous name on the receiver.
Months in the used bolt-action rifle Top 5: January (No. 4), February (No. 4), March (No. 3), April (No. 3)
The Savage 99 appeared in the used lever-action rifle Top 5 in six of the nine months covered, including No. 3 in April and No. 4 in May, June, July and August.
Introduced in 1899, the hammerless Savage 99 used a rotary magazine that safely handled pointed bullets, setting it apart from tube-fed lever guns of its era. Its long production run and classic lines make a used 99 a standout gift for the vintage lever-gun enthusiast.
Months in the used lever-action rifle Top 5: January (No. 5), April (No. 3), May (No. 4), June (No. 4), July (No. 4), August (No. 4)
The Remington 700 Mountain ranked No. 1 among used bolt-action rifles in February and March and No. 2 in April, earning a spot on this list with three Top 5 finishes, two of them at No. 1.
The Mountain version trims weight from the classic Model 700 with a slimmer profile built for hunters who carry their rifle long distances. For the elk or mule deer hunter who covers big country on foot, a used 700 Mountain is a practical, purpose-built gift.
Months in the used bolt-action rifle Top 5: February (No. 1), March (No. 1), April (No. 2)
The Ruger No. 3 made the used single-shot rifle Top 5 four times, placing No. 5 in February, No. 1 in March and April, and No. 3 in May. March and April were the only months the Ruger No. 1 did not lead the category.
Made from the early 1970s to the late 1980s, the No. 3 is a simpler, carbine-style take on Ruger’s falling-block design. Its out-of-production status makes it a natural gift for the single-shot collector.
Months in the used single-shot rifle Top 5: February (No. 5), March (No. 1), April (No. 1), May (No. 3)
The Ruger M77 made the used bolt-action rifle Top 5 in all nine months covered, ranking No. 3 in January and No. 4 in every month from April through September.
Introduced in 1968, the M77 earned a reputation as a rugged, dependable hunting rifle, and the Mark II version that followed in the early 1990s added a three-position safety. A used M77 is a strong pick for the hunter who wants a no-nonsense workhorse.
Months in the used bolt-action rifle Top 5: January (No. 3), February (No. 5), March (No. 5), April (No. 4), May (No. 4), June (No. 4), July (No. 4), August (No. 4), September (No. 4)
The Remington Rolling Block finished in the used single-shot rifle Top 5 in all nine months covered, with its best finishes at No. 3 in March, July and September.
Developed in the 1860s, the rolling-block action armed militaries and hunters around the world, and modern reproductions keep the design in circulation today. For the history buff who enjoys frontier-era firearms, a used Rolling Block is a gift with a story.
Months in the used single-shot rifle Top 5: January (No. 4), February (No. 4), March (No. 3), April (No. 5), May (No. 4), June (No. 4), July (No. 3), August (No. 4), September (No. 3)
The Remington 700 BDL appeared in the used bolt-action rifle Top 5 in eight of the nine months covered and ranked No. 3 in February and in every month from May through September.
The BDL is the dressed-up version of the Model 700, with a checkered walnut stock, glossy finish and hinged floorplate. For the hunter who loves the look of walnut and blued steel, a used 700 BDL is a classic gift.
Months in the used bolt-action rifle Top 5: February (No. 3), March (No. 4), April (No. 5), May (No. 3), June (No. 3), July (No. 3), August (No. 3), September (No. 3)
The Marlin 336 finished in the used lever-action rifle Top 5 in seven of the nine months covered, ranking No. 2 in January and June and No. 3 in May, July, August and September.
Introduced in 1948, the 336 uses a solid-top receiver with side ejection, which makes mounting a scope straightforward. Commonly chambered in .30-30 Winchester, it is a time-tested gift for the brush-country deer hunter.
Months in the used lever-action rifle Top 5: January (No. 2), February (No. 4), May (No. 3), June (No. 2), July (No. 3), August (No. 3), September (No. 3)
🎥 Binge Watch GunBroker Product Spotlight Videos
The Thompson/Center Encore made the used single-shot rifle Top 5 in seven of the nine months covered, finishing No. 2 in January, February, May and June.
The break-action Encore is built around interchangeable barrels, so one frame can be set up for different cartridges and hunting seasons. That versatility makes a used Encore an excellent gift for the hunter who pursues more than one kind of game.
Months in the used single-shot rifle Top 5: January (No. 2), February (No. 2), April (No. 4), May (No. 2), June (No. 2), August (No. 3), September (No. 4)
The New England Firearms Handi-Rifle appeared in the used single-shot rifle Top 5 in all nine months covered, with No. 2 finishes in April, July and September.
The simple, break-action Handi-Rifle has long been an affordable, easy-to-learn choice and a popular first rifle for new hunters. A used Handi-Rifle is a thoughtful gift for a young or new hunter.
Months in the used single-shot rifle Top 5: January (No. 3), February (No. 3), March (No. 5), April (No. 2), May (No. 5), June (No. 3), July (No. 2), August (No. 5), September (No. 2)
The Remington 700 ranked No. 1 among used bolt-action rifles in every month it appeared in the Top 5: January and May through September, for six No. 1 finishes in the nine months covered.
Introduced in 1962, the Model 700 became one of the most widely used bolt-action rifles in the country for hunting, and its action also served as the basis for the U.S. Army’s M24 sniper system. Broad aftermarket support makes a used 700 an easy gift for the big-game hunter.
Months in the used bolt-action rifle Top 5: January (No. 1), May (No. 1), June (No. 1), July (No. 1), August (No. 1), September (No. 1)
The Winchester 1894 appeared in the used lever-action rifle Top 5 in eight of the nine months covered. It ranked No. 1 in February, No. 2 in March, April, May, July, August and September, and No. 3 in June.
GunBroker’s data tracks the Winchester 1894 separately from the Model 94. The 1894 name covers rifles marked with the design’s original model name, including newer Winchester 1894 production. For the lever-action collector, it is a gift rooted in one of the most celebrated designs in American hunting.
Months in the used lever-action rifle Top 5: February (No. 1), March (No. 2), April (No. 2), May (No. 2), June (No. 3), July (No. 2), August (No. 2), September (No. 2)
The Winchester Model 70 was the only rifle on this list to finish in the Top 2 of its category in all nine months covered. It ranked No. 1 among used bolt-action rifles in April and No. 2 in every other month.
Introduced in 1936 and long known as “The Rifleman’s Rifle,” the Model 70 is prized for its classic lines, and pre-1964 rifles with controlled-round feed are especially sought after by collectors. A used Model 70 is a gift for the hunter who values tradition.
Months in the used bolt-action rifle Top 5: January (No. 2), February (No. 2), March (No. 2), April (No. 1), May (No. 2), June (No. 2), July (No. 2), August (No. 2), September (No. 2)
The Winchester 94 ranked No. 1 among used lever-action rifles in every month it appeared in the Top 5: January and March through September. Its eight No. 1 finishes were the most of any rifle on this list.
Designed by John Browning and introduced as the Model 1894, the Winchester 94 is closely associated with the .30-30 Winchester cartridge and generations of whitetail hunters. Lightweight, quick-handling and easy to carry, a used Model 94 is a classic gift for the deer camp traditionalist.
Months in the used lever-action rifle Top 5: January (No. 1), March (No. 1), April (No. 1), May (No. 1), June (No. 1), July (No. 1), August (No. 1), September (No. 1)
No used hunting rifle ranked higher on GunBroker during the nine months covered than the Ruger No. 1. It ranked No. 1 among used single-shot rifles in seven of the nine months covered, finished No. 2 in March and No. 3 in April, and appeared in the category Top 5 every month.
Introduced in the late 1960s, the No. 1 is built on a falling-block action that gives it a short overall length and classic, elegant lines. Offered over the years in a wide range of chamberings, a used No. 1 is a refined gift for the hunter who prefers making one well-placed shot count.
Months in the used single-shot rifle Top 5: January (No. 1), February (No. 1), March (No. 2), April (No. 3), May (No. 1), June (No. 1), July (No. 1), August (No. 1), September (No. 1)
The Ruger No. 1 (single shot), Winchester 94 (lever action) and Winchester Model 70 (bolt action) finished first, second and third, giving each action type a model in the top three.
Across all three categories and all nine months, every No. 1 used hunting rifle finish went to a model in this guide, led by the Winchester 94 with eight No. 1 finishes, the Ruger No. 1 with seven and the Remington 700 with six.
Remington placed four rifles (700, 700 BDL, Rolling Block and 700 Mountain), while Winchester (94, Model 70 and 1894) and Ruger (No. 1, M77 and No. 3) placed three each. New England Firearms, Thompson/Center, Marlin, Savage and Mauser each placed one.
Six of the 15 picks were bolt-action rifles, but five single-shot rifles also made the list, including the No. 1 overall Ruger No. 1. Lever actions claimed four spots, two of them in the top five.
Most of the list traces its roots to designs from the 1860s through the 1960s, from the Rolling Block and Winchester 94 to the Model 70, Marlin 336 and Remington 700, with the modern Mauser M12 the newest design included.
From the Ruger No. 1’s run atop the single-shot rankings to the Winchester 94’s hold on lever actions, this year’s best-selling used hunting rifles on GunBroker spanned every major action type. Each pick earned its place on nine months of real sales data, giving gift shoppers a proven starting point.
Ready to find the right rifle for the hunter on your list? Browse used rifles on GunBroker.com, review each listing carefully and follow all applicable federal, state and local laws and transfer requirements.
Shopping for a handgun owner, too? See our companion Holiday Gift Guide: Top 15 Used Handguns on GunBroker.